Considerations for the Use of Transgenics in Phytoremediation.
(Glass et al.)
It seems clear that using transgenic plants (Hg model
and Cd model at this site) is not only a possibility but can provide tremendous
potential for enhancing phytoremediation of heavy metals.
Field Trials, Field Trials, Field Trials!
New genes and their functions are currently being investigated.
It is important to note that engineering plants should not be the only
strategy utilized in a phytoremediation project but complement strategies
implemented. Moreover, there are potential risks in using genetically
modified plants as phytoremediators. Introduced DNA and the vectors
that contain them should be well characterized. Extensive field trials
using transgenics in phytoremediation have not been reported and must be
done to investigate their potential in the field.
Considerations
Two important considerations for any transgenic plant
desired for use are i) potential weediness and ii) the ability
to outcross
Potential Weediness:
-
Some plants are subject to weediness by single gene changes although
usually several gene changes are necessary. Extensive agriculturally
bred plants are less likely to exhibit this phenomenon. However,
most potential species for phytoremediation are not agriculturally significant.
Therefore, one must investigate in the literature, field, and laboratory,
whether single gene changes do provide a growth advantage or weediness.
It
is the opinion of this author that transgenic plants used in phytoremediation
would not offer any advantage outside of the contaminated site containing
the pollutant the said plant is engineered to remediate.
Outcrossing:
-
The ability to outcross is dependent on several factors. Are there
any relatives near the plant of interest? Is it possible to control
for pollination by harvesting plants before flowering or by removing pollen-producing
organs. Is the contaminated area isolated from related species?
There is a possibility transgenic plants could cross with near-by food
crops conferring undesirable accumulation in the food crop species.
However, as David Glass points out, "the proximity of such food crops to
hazardous waste would be more troubling than the remote possibility of
a single gene transfer across species."
Home. The
mer
Operon and Mercury Phytoremediation. Phytochelatin
Synthesis and Cadmium What is Phytoremediation?
Hg risk assessment. Other
Transgenics. Links and References.